Chuck Schumer has guarded his pet green card lottery for decades and sneers that critics are just politicizing tragedy.
Now FBI Director Kash Patel is chasing a fraud ring that has robbed taxpayers from coast to coast.
And one defendant’s immigration paperwork points right back at Schumer’s handiwork.
The FBI Found 830,000 College Students Who Don’t Exist
Somebody has been signing up Americans for college classes without bothering to tell them. Hundreds of thousands of them.
Heith Janke, the assistant director of the FBI’s Criminal Division, told ABC News that agents now know of 830,000 fraudulent student aid accounts tied to more than $130 million in stolen money. He said almost half of the bureau’s 55 field offices have “ghost student” cases open right now.
“We are just getting started when it comes to ghost students,” Janke said.
The con runs on a simple formula. Crooks grab a working American’s name and Social Security number, usually from somebody who never went to college. They file a federal student aid application in that person’s name, enroll the phantom at a school (often an open-door community college), and wait for the school to cut a refund check after tuition comes off the top. Then the cash hops through bank accounts and crypto wallets until it lands overseas.
According to the Justice Department, some fraudsters even put artificial intelligence to work finishing the coursework so their fake students looked busy enough to keep the aid flowing.
Big Tech keeps selling AI as a miracle for the American worker. Fraud rings found a use for it first.
Tony Rice learned all this the hard way. The Wisconsin cybersecurity professional discovered that someone had opened a student loan of roughly $10,000 in his name.
“I’ve never been to college a single day in my life,” Rice said.
Prosecutors Chased the Cash All the Way to Nairobi
The Justice Department recently announced the first charges from Operation Ghostbusters, naming five defendants across Virginia, New Jersey, and Nebraska. Investigators also grabbed more than $750,000 in cryptocurrency from a Kenyan national’s account with help from Kenyan police, a first for the department’s fraud unit.
Assistant Attorney General Colin McDonald, who runs the new National Fraud Enforcement Division, didn’t mince words.
“Whether you are in Nebraska, New Jersey, Virginia, or Nairobi, we will pursue you,” McDonald said.
Prosecutors in Virginia accuse a Kenyan national, whose case remains under seal, of acting as a stateside money mule who collected more than 700 fraudulent aid refunds worth about $1.44 million. In New Jersey, prosecutors say three people pocketed their cut and wired the rest to partners in Kenya connected with a purported safari company.
Every one of them gets the presumption of innocence.
But the Nebraska case carries the detail Washington Democrats will least want to discuss.
A Lottery Ticket Came With a Green Card Attached
Francis Mogambi, a 23-year-old Kenyan citizen living in Lincoln, faces five counts of theft of government money and five counts of aggravated identity theft. Prosecutors allege he used stolen American identities from November 2025 through May 2026 to enroll victims in schools, kept 30 percent of each aid check, and shipped the rest to associates in Kenya.
His own roommate turned him in, according to court records ABC News reviewed. The Justice Department says Mogambi tried to recruit that roommate, bragged that he pulled in $2,000 a week, and talked about needing a business so he could cash bigger checks without paying taxes.
And here’s the kicker. Mogambi arrived in the United States on May 15, 2024, with Joe Biden in the White House. He came on a DV1 visa after winning the Diversity Visa lottery and received a green card shortly after, according to federal prosecutors.
Read that one twice. Washington handed permanent residency to a young man because his name came up in a drawing, and prosecutors say he went to work stealing American identities about 18 months later.
To be clear about the numbers, the indictment pegs his alleged take at roughly $20,000. That’s pocket change next to the Virginia case, and one defendant can’t stand in for a whole program.
But nobody defending the lottery has ever explained what a raffle tells the government about a newcomer that a skills test wouldn’t tell it better.
Chuck Schumer Built This Raffle
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) sponsored the original diversity visa proposal back in 1990, while he still served in the House. Congress rolled it into the Immigration Act of 1990, and the program now offers up to 50,000 green cards a year by lottery to people from countries that send few immigrants to America.
Nearly 20 million people entered the drawing for 2025, according to NPR.
Choosing future Americans by lottery ticket makes about as much sense as picking a heart surgeon out of a hat. Skills don’t count. English doesn’t count. Whether a newcomer will ever assimilate doesn’t count. Luck counts. And when the country imports people at nation-changing volumes with no regard for those questions, communities pay the bill.
President Trump called this out in 2017, after an Uzbek immigrant who entered through the same program drove a rented truck down a Manhattan bike path and killed eight people.
“The terrorist came into our country through what is called ‘Diversity Visa Lottery Program,’ a Chuck Schumer beauty. I want merit based,” Trump posted at the time.
Schumer fired back by accusing Trump of politicizing the attack. Then the lottery kept right on spinning.
A Homeland Security spokesperson later laid out what happened next: “POTUS Trump supported legislative efforts like the RAISE Act to eliminate the diversity visa lottery. This was stopped by Chuck Schumer and Democrats.”
Schumer did offer to scrap the lottery once. He tucked that offer inside the 2013 Gang of Eight bill, which would have handed amnesty to millions of illegal aliens. That deal would have traded a 50,000-a-year raffle for a mass amnesty, a bargain that only makes sense to a party shopping for a fresh crop of voters.
Trump suspended diversity visa processing in 2020. Biden restarted it. And after authorities identified a lottery winner as the suspect in the deadly Brown University shooting in December 2025, Trump directed Kristi Noem to pause the program “to ensure no more Americans are harmed by this disastrous program,” in Noem’s words.
By then, Mogambi had already been in the country for more than a year and a half.
Biden’s Open Door at the Financial Aid Office
Investigators believe the ghost student racket took off around 2021, the year Biden’s team took over the Education Department. Trump’s Education Department says the Biden-Harris administration rolled back key verification safeguards during the COVID era, until fewer than 1 percent of students had to prove their identity after filing for aid.
California’s community colleges logged 1.2 million fraudulent applications in 2024 alone, according to an Associated Press analysis of state fraud reports. Those produced about 223,000 suspected fake enrollments.
The Trump administration slammed that door. Education Secretary Linda McMahon’s department now runs identity screening right inside the federal aid application, and high-risk applicants must show a government ID before they see a dime.
“American citizens have to present an ID to drive a car, to get on a plane,” James Bergeron, the department’s acting student aid chief operating officer, told Fox News Digital.
Under Secretary Nicholas Kent says the crackdown has saved taxpayers more than $2 billion in attempted student aid theft.
“Every dollar that falls into the hands of a fraudster is a dollar that will not go to a student in need,” Kent said.
JD Vance chairs the White House task force on fraud that sits behind the whole operation.
Senate Democrats Hold the Next Move
Real students take a hit too. A Treasury Department alert warned this summer that fake enrollees have jammed some classes so badly that genuine students struggle to get a seat.
The House passed the No Aid for Ghost Students bill in June. It would make schools verify students before any aid goes out the door. But the bill never cleared the Senate.
Janke vowed that “we will trace the money, we will find it, and we will seek accountability from them.”
Federal agents can chase the money. Only Congress can close the doors it left open.
So when Democrats take over the Senate in January, will Chuck Schumer’s caucus bring the ghost student bill to a vote, or will the first fight be over getting his lottery spinning again?
Sources: US Department of Justice, Eastern District of Virginia press release on Operation Ghostbusters indictments; ABC News, “‘It’s appalling’: Feds ramp up investigations of ‘ghost student’ fraud”; 6abc Philadelphia, “‘Operation Ghostbusters’: 5 charged in alleged financial aid scheme”; TechSpot, “‘Ghost students’ stole millions in federal aid until data patterns gave them away”; Fox News Digital, “Trump admin requiring gov issued ID to apply for federal student aid saved $200 million in fraud in 2 months”; Associated Press analysis via Yahoo News, “Scammers are using AI to enroll fake students in online classes”; American Thinker, “Operation Ghostbusters finds widespread education fraud”; NPR, “Trump suspends US green card lottery after Brown University and MIT shootings”; Axios, “What to know about the diversity immigrant visas halted after Brown shooting”; Campus Reform, “Trump admin pauses diversity visa program”; PolitiFact and FactCheck.org on Schumer and the diversity visa lottery; Axios, “Trump blames Schumer-proposed immigration program for NYC attack”



