JD Vance stands as the clear America First heir for 2028, and the Republican old guard is already shopping for anybody else.
Their newest pitch sounds harmless until somebody reads the résumés.
And JD Vance just learned which governors made the shortlist.
The Old Guard Wrote a Job Description With One Name Missing
After the midterm rout, one question keeps popping up in donor circles and on cable panels. How about a governor?
CNN counted at least four current or former Republican governors flashing national ambitions. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, Georgia Governor Brian Kemp, Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders, and former Virginia Governor Glenn Youngkin have all left the 2028 door cracked open.
Two others went a step further. Utah Governor Spencer Cox and Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt have both said this year that they’d prefer the next nominee come out of a governor’s mansion.
Read that requirement one more time. It isn’t a qualification so much as a filter. Vance served in the Marines, built a career investing in Midwest businesses, won a Senate seat in Ohio, and now serves as Vice President. The one box he can’t check happens to be the box the old guard suddenly discovered matters more than anything else.
Funny how that works.
Former Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker made the sales pitch to CNN, arguing that “being able to get things done and being removed are kind of like the magic one-two punch.”
But Walker, of all people, knows how far a governor’s résumé travels on its own. His 2016 presidential campaign folded in September 2015, months before a single Iowan walked into a caucus.
Marc Short, who ran former Vice President Mike Pence’s office, told CNN the midterm losses pried the door open wider. “I think it was such a shellacking and a rejection of the last two years that they’ll have to be candidates who look and say, ‘Maybe there’s an opening for me,'” Short said.
Pence ran against Donald Trump in the 2024 primary and then refused to endorse him. That’s the crowd celebrating the opening.
Spencer Cox Shared His Pronouns With a Room Full of Teenagers
Start with Cox, since he’s one of the two men openly writing the governors-only rule.
During an April 2021 virtual town hall with high school students, Cox answered a girl’s question by telling her “my preferred pronouns are he, him, his so thank you for sharing yours with me.” Conservative reporters later noticed “he/him” sitting in his Instagram bio. The pronouns quietly disappeared once people started asking about them.
Then came the veto. In March 2022, Utah lawmakers passed HB11 to keep boys out of girls’ high school sports, and Cox killed it.
“I believe in fairness and protecting the integrity of women’s sports,” Cox wrote in his veto letter. He then vetoed the bill designed to protect them.
Legislators didn’t buy it. They overrode him three days later.
Charlie Kirk wanted Cox drummed out of the Republican Party over that veto. And when Cox spoke at Turning Point USA’s first big gathering after Kirk’s assassination, part of the crowd booed him. Those folks had long memories, and they’d earned them.
The pattern runs deeper than one bill. Cox wrote in other names rather than vote for Trump in 2016 and 2020. After January 6, he called on Trump to resign. Two days before the Butler assassination attempt in July 2024, he told CNN he wouldn’t vote for Trump that fall either. A week later, he flipped and endorsed him.
Cox also lurched right in 2024, the same year he faced a primary challenge from state Representative Phil Lyman. He signed a bathroom bill and started describing child gender procedures as mutilation. Voters can decide how much an election-year conversion weighs against the rest of the record.
Asked recently by NPR whether Trump had united the country, Cox didn’t hedge. “I think if you were to ask him that question, he would say no. I don’t think that’s happened,” Cox said.
Brian Kemp’s Biggest Fans Were Mike Pence and George W Bush
Kemp’s break came in late 2020. Millions of Republican voters wanted hard questions answered about how Georgia ran that election, and Trump repeatedly asked Kemp to call state lawmakers back for a special session. Kemp turned him down every time.
Trump responded by recruiting former US Senator David Perdue to challenge Kemp in the 2022 primary. Kemp buried Perdue with nearly 75 percent of the vote. The endorsement list told the whole story, with Pence and George W Bush both lining up behind the incumbent.
The two men have patched things up since. One Georgia Republican strategist told CNN that “Trump was mad at him at certain times, but he wasn’t mad at Trump.”
Maybe so. But Kemp’s latest stretch hardly screams national juggernaut. He endorsed candidates for Senate and governor who lost their primaries, then campaigned for the nominees, Mike Collins and Rick Jackson, who both lost to Democrats. Georgia now has a Democrat Party further emboldened to push government-run health care and higher taxes on working families.
Senate Republicans reportedly want Kemp to take on Democrat Senator Raphael Warnock in 2028 instead. That might tell readers what the party’s own strategists think of his presidential odds.
Kevin Stitt Wants Governors Handing Out Work Permits
Stitt didn’t wait long to show what a governor-led Republican Party might look like. Speaking to Politico at a National Governors Association forum for incoming governors, the outgoing Oklahoma Governor laid out his immigration fix.
“It’s as simple as if an employer is vouching for an employee, the state governor should be able to issue that workforce permit. Period. End of story,” Stitt said.
He even attached a price tag. “Let’s charge that employer $2,500 to go towards our national debt,” Stitt said.
Peel off the wrapping paper and that plan hands illegal aliens a permit to stay as long as some boss vouches for them. The business pays a fee smaller than the down payment on a used pickup. American workers absorb the cost through lower wages, and Democrats wait patiently for the day a “temporary” permit becomes a green card and a voter registration card.
That’s amnesty. Limiting both illegal and legal immigration unites the Republican base like nothing else, and Stitt chose the weeks right after Republicans lost Congress to float the Chamber of Commerce wish list. Establishment Republicans always seem to find their amnesty courage once Trump’s time on the clock starts running short.
Vance didn’t let it slide. “But to a lot of people, this sounds like an effort to give amnesty to people who have broken our laws,” Vance wrote on X. “It is morally and electorally disastrous.”
The Governor Ticket Already Flopped for the Old Guard
The establishment has run this play before.
In 2012, the party handed its nomination to a former Massachusetts governor whose state health care law became the blueprint for Obamacare. Mitt Romney lost to Barack Obama. In 2016, Jeb Bush rode a super PAC haul north of $100 million and walked away from the race after South Carolina with a handful of delegates.
That 2016 field was packed with governors. Bush, John Kasich, Chris Christie, Rick Perry, Bobby Jindal, Mike Huckabee, George Pataki, Jim Gilmore, and Walker himself all ran. A businessman from Queens with zero days in public office beat every one of them.
US Senator John Cornyn (R-TX) sounded a similar note to CNN. “If I had to guess, I would say an outsider has a better chance than someone who’s a member of the current administration,” Cornyn said.
Cornyn backed amnesty measures and championed Joe Biden’s gun control bill before Republican primary voters showed him the door. He also questioned whether Vance would stay in Trump’s good graces after Vance blamed the Iran war for the party’s losses.
But Trump himself already weighed in on that one. “Actually, it was a very accurate statement,” Trump said of Vance’s diagnosis.
The voters agree. About one Republican in four told CBS News exit pollsters the strikes on Iran were a mistake, a crack inside the party’s own coalition that the neocons who sold the war would rather nobody notice. Among Trump 2024 voters who’ve since cooled on him, Echelon Insights found the wars, Iran included, drew 15 percent of the blame while tariffs barely registered at 3.
So the old guard’s alibi needs a scapegoat. Vance makes a convenient one.
Even Trump’s Former Press Secretary Sees the Scoreboard
Not every governor on CNN’s list fits the old guard’s mold. Huckabee Sanders, who served as Trump’s White House press secretary, told HBO’s Real Time with Bill Maher that Vance “starts with a tremendous lead.”
And the man who stood at Trump’s podium for two years knows the base better than the strategists dreaming up job descriptions.
Democrats, meanwhile, couldn’t be happier. With both chambers headed their way in January and a socialist wing hungry for a fight over amnesty, court packing, and government-run medicine, nothing would please them more than two years of Republicans tearing each other apart over a résumé technicality.
The establishment keeps insisting this conversation is about executive experience. Kevin Stitt answered the Vice President’s amnesty warning by thanking him “for bringing governors into the conversation.”
Sources: CNN, “Republicans seeking an alternative to JD Vance ask: How about a governor?”; Breitbart; Raw Story; The National News Desk; Washington Examiner; KSL; Salt Lake Tribune; ABC News; CBS News; NPR; National Review; The Federalist; Axios; The Hill; Atlanta Journal-Constitution; Boston Globe; Ballotpedia; PBS NewsHour.



