Senate Majority Leader John Thune just handed gloating Democrats the Senate, and he swears none of it was his fault.
Donald Trump has his own theory about who left Republicans stranded.
And John Thune just read off a list of culprits on Fox News that leaves out one obvious name.
John Thune Put Every Culprit on the List but One
Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD) went on Fox News Channel’s America Reports and got the question Republican voters have been yelling at their television sets since November 3.
Co-anchor John Roberts said he was still stunned that Republicans let Democrats own the message on the issues voters cared about. He wanted to know how the party plans to get it back.
Thune had his answer loaded. “Well, I think part of it, John, any exit poll that you look at would tell you it was about the war, it was about the economy, it was about inflation, it was about gas prices,” he said.
Then he added the sentence that gave the whole game away. “I think that’s what it came down to, none of which the candidates had much control over.”
Look at what made the list. The war, the grocery bill, the pump. Every item lands in the act-of-God column, like a hailstorm that rolled through and flattened the crop.
And look at what didn’t make it. Not one thing on Thune’s list happened on the floor of the chamber he runs.
His fix sounded like it came straight off a consultant’s whiteboard. Thune said Republicans lost independents “by 30 percentage points” in the key Senate races and need to start “delivering an economic message about the cost of living, the things that the American people care about.”
Donald Trump Pointed Straight at the Senate
Donald Trump read the same results and reached a very different verdict.
Days after the election, the President took to Truth Social and aimed at the one room Thune left out. “The Republican Senate can no longer be the place ‘where things are sent to die,’” Trump wrote. “Not passing THE SAVE AMERICA ACT (Voter I.D., Proof of Citizenship), sent up five times by the House, was devastating to the Republican Party in the Midterms.”
And he didn’t stop there. “Not terminating the Filibuster, and getting EVERYTHING even ‘dreamt’ of, approved, when the Dems will definitely do so, will go down as being one of the greatest mistakes in the Political History of America,” Trump added.
The same post congratulated Thune on winning another term as the top Senate Republican.
The SAVE America Act would make Americans prove their citizenship before registering to vote in federal elections. It’s about as commonsense as election integrity gets, since only American citizens should decide American elections. But the House kept sending it over, and the Senate kept letting it die. Senate Republicans voted on the bill in whole or in part at least five times and never got anywhere near the 60 votes the filibuster demands.
Back in July, Trump told Thune to cancel the August recess until the Senate either passed the bill or scrapped the filibuster.
But Thune said the votes weren’t there and let everybody leave town.
Thune’s Explanation Changed With the Weather
Here’s the funny part. Thune’s list of culprits has already shuffled once.
Right after his colleagues handed him another term as leader without a challenger, Thune said, “I think it was a combination of things and, most importantly, it was the cost of living for the American people.” A week later on Fox, the war jumped to the front of the line.
The order changes. The location never does. Every cause Thune names lives somewhere other than the Senate floor.
And while Thune blamed gas prices, plenty of his members blamed the White House. Senate Republicans came back to the Capitol furious with Trump, according to The Hill, and some argued he hurt them by constantly hammering their failure to pass the SAVE America Act. Thune’s leadership team wanted candidates talking up the tax cuts in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act instead.
Chew on that one. The senators who couldn’t pass the bill got mad at the man who kept reminding voters they couldn’t pass the bill.
The Missing Voters Weren’t Independents
Thune wants Republicans chasing “the middle of the electorate.” The numbers say the party lost its own front porch first.
Pollster J.L. Partners checked an Election Day survey against tens of thousands of campaign interviews and found that more than a third of the people who voted for Trump in 2024 simply skipped the midterms. Fewer than one in ten of them crossed over to vote for Democrats.
“Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House,” said James Johnson, the firm’s founding director.
The no-shows tilted older, too. Among Trump’s 2024 voters over 65, 44 percent sat this one out, according to the firm’s data.
These aren’t fickle swing voters. They’re the folks who never miss an election, the ones standing in the church parking lot before the polls open. And when that crowd stays home, a slicker pitch about grocery prices isn’t going to coax them back out.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis said the quiet part the day after the election. “A lot of our voters who stayed home, they stayed home because they were frustrated with the lack of productivity from Republicans in the House and Senate,” DeSantis said.
Granted, no Senate leader sets the price of diesel. And the war belongs to the neoconservatives who spent months pushing the President toward it. NBC News exit polling found 63 percent of voters saying the US made the wrong decision in taking military action against Iran, with Democrats pulling in 83 percent of them. Thune can file that one under forces beyond his control, but the hawks who sold it should get the bill.
But the SAVE America Act was never a hailstorm. It sat in Thune’s building, on Thune’s calendar, for months. A Majority Leader decides what gets floor time, how long the Senate stays in town, and how hard he leans on the members who won’t budge. Thune made every one of those calls, and he made them the way the old guard always does.
That’s the establishment routine. Smile for the cameras, praise the President’s agenda in public, then explain why the rules make it impossible. The donors who want the pre-Trump party back never needed Thune to kill the bill outright. They just needed him to shrug.
Democrats Won’t Waste Their Majority on Excuses
Come January, Democrats take the gavel, and Thune moves into the minority leader’s office still guarding the filibuster.
Trump already called the next move. Democrats will scrap the 60-vote rule the moment it stands between them and amnesty for illegal aliens, a Supreme Court stuffed with new justices, or statehood for Washington, DC and Puerto Rico. They won’t hold a single press conference explaining that the votes weren’t there. They’ll go find them.
Maybe Thune truly believes his independents theory. Some swing voters surely walked over prices. But a leader who can’t name one thing his own chamber could have done differently isn’t running a recovery. He’s writing an alibi.
John Thune told Fox News the midterms turned on forces no Republican candidate could control. For a few more weeks, the Senate floor schedule still sits on his desk.
Sources: Breitbart, “Thune: GOP Midterm Losses ‘About the War’ and ‘Economy’”; The Hill, “Trump points to Senate Republicans over midterm losses: ‘Devastating’”; The Hill, “Senate Republicans return to Capitol furious with Trump after big losses”; Yahoo News, “Trump Blames GOP Midterm Rout on Voter ID Failure”; The National News Desk, “Trump reapplies pressure on Senate Republicans ahead of Democratic takeover”; 2paragraphs, “Trump Blames Senate Republicans for Midterm Rout — Thune: ‘Cost of Living’”; Political Wire, “Trump Voters Who Stayed Home Cost GOP Midterms”; Townhall, “A New Analysis Has a Troubling Explanation for the Republican Midterm Wipeout”; MENAFN, “Poll Finds 35 Percent of Trump’s 2024 Voters Skipped Midterms”; Mediaite, “DeSantis Outright Says ‘This Midterm, No Question, Was a Rebuke’ of Trump”; NBC News exit polling



